Rating sheet

From Drmills

RATING SHEET

Scale: 1 - 5 (5 is best)

___ quality of proposal

___ discovered, integrated and synthesized relevant information about the topic

___ critical analysis of information (of both corroborating and non-corroborating evidence)

___ conclusions based on empirical evidence (when available),  not simply opinion

___ written in an impartial, objective tone

___ the contribution fits in well with the existing outline and material

___ writing is of high quality: interesting, flows, analytic, good argumentation, organized

___ used APA style referencing appropriately (including reference list)

___ included relevant graphics (tables, histograms, photos, etc.).

___ included a list of relevant external web links for more information

Note: If you revise the above, per the revision suggestions, and replace the corresponding material in the wiki book, your grade will be adjusted upward by up to 1/2 grade.